Lunar Gunsight Redux

Dave Johnston

Well-Known Member
As posted last month, after a lot of planning I was able to capture the moon rising into Gunsight Notch in Seneca Rocks, West Virginia. As it happens, the next opportunity to catch that alignment was the next month, on December 27. (No it doesn't happen every month, but is more likely during the late fall and winter.) The location for this was at a greater angle to the plane of the rocks, and the original viewpoint I had identified was low and closer to the rocks than before. So I didn't have high hopes for it being any better an image than I had already done. But since the weather was clear and not bitterly cold, I decided to take a look. When I got there I found the lower location that I had planned had trees impinging on the lower part of the cliffs, which I didn't like. But I pulled out my phone version of TPE and was able to plot locations further back along the path that the view would be possible, and found that there was a view in an open field further back. This had the added advantage of the moon rising earlier, about 20 minutes before sunset, so I figured I'd have more light on the rocks.

When I set up at that new position, and the time approached, I began to realize that this time of the year the sun sets far enough south that the mountains to the southwest are lower, meaning that the direct light of the setting sun will play on the rocks longer than other times of the year. I waited breathlessly while the last sunset light climbed up the hill below the rocks as the time for the moon appearance got closer, hoping it would last long enough. As it happened, I had about 2 minutes of warm, soft sunset light on the cliffs while the moon rose into the notch. That was just enough time to get a good composition where everything came together.

Below are the color and black and white versions of what I got.

Edit: I forgot to mention - note the climbers on the cliff to the right.

Lunar Gunsight II-1.jpg


Lunar Gunsight II-1 BW.jpg


Comments and suggestions welcome.

Dave
 
Last edited:

JimFox

Moderator
Staff member
Perfect planning Dave! It’s great that you were able to go out and shoot that again.

Both of these are super cool. If I were to see either one without the other, I would be happy. I think as much as I really really like the B&W version, I would give a slight nod to the color version because of the warmth of the rocks. But again, both are totally awesome!
 

Ben Egbert

Forum Helper
Staff member
Totally awesome is a perfect description, both meet that requirement. I love the B&W and you did a great job processing it. The color is my choice for the same reason as Jim's. I am impressed that you were using a long enough focal length to get a large moon and still had great dof and prefect exposure for the moon. Not only good planning, but great technique and post processing.
 

Jameel Hyder

Moderator
Staff member
Echo both Ben’s and Jim’s sentiments. My nod to the color version as well. If you had some puffy clouds to fill the upper part of the image it would be 20 out of 10.
 

Dave Johnston

Well-Known Member
Thanks, Jim, Ben and Jameel. Like all of you, I am partial to the color one, since the warm glow on the cliffs both balances and contrasts with the sky and the moon. I really was lucky to catch that combination, I had not planned for or anticipated that, though the planning helped me be in the right place and time to take advantage of it. But I was also really struck by how well the black and white turned out under the same conditions. That is something to keep in mind for future B&W opportunities.

Ben, I prefocused on the rocks and added just a slight nudge toward longer focus in anticipation of the moon, so both were easily within the hyperfocal distance. If I zoom to 100%, I can see that the moon is not quite as sharp as it would have been if I had focused on it, but it would still stand up to a pretty large print.

Jameel yes, last month the moon peeking through the clouds added a lot of drama to the sky, and this month the clearer sky was less interesting. But puffy clouds are something I can look forward to at a future opportunity!

Dave
 

AlanLichty

Moderator
Well done - your backstory makes the result all the more interesting. I prefer the color with the warm tones on the cliff faces contrasting with the blue sky and the moon.
 
This is really nice, Dave. The way you frame your black and white images and the quality of the images remind me of Ansel Adams books on photography. Happy New Year.
 

Dave Johnston

Well-Known Member
Thank you Douglas, Jeffrey and pepper!

BTW Gunsight Notch used to be even more deserving of its name. There used to be a thin vertical rock, about 15 feet high, sticking up in the middle of the notch, called The Gendarme. It was very unstable and fell in 1987.

Dave
 
Top Bottom